Nightbane: The Dynamics of Collaboration & Designing for External Stakeholders

alex brazie pos mortem-world of warcraft nightbane

Game: World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade
Game Element: Nightbane, the final boss in Return to Karazhan
Discipline: Content Design

Side note: There are references to design conversations with an individual who has been accused of inexcusable acts.

However, the lessons told by those stories are worth sharing with those who didn’t have access to this information.

Some names have been redacted where appropriate, but the lesson is preserved for everyone to learn from freely.

In this journey, we’ll explore the unique challenges faced when working on a boss encounter assigned by individuals outside the core boss team.

As a combat designer, I was tasked with creating a formidable and unforgiving fight, and I embraced the challenge with enthusiasm.

Join me as we delve into the intricacies of designing a challenging encounter that tests the limits of players’ skill and determination.

Questionable Origins

A. A.: Yes, yes, come in to my office, Mr. Brazie.

Me: Hey dude, Scott said you needed me to make a quest boss for you?

A. A.: A quest boss? No sir, what I need from you is excellence!!

Me: Uhm… okay?

A. A.: This is no mere quest boss, this will be a secret, unlockable raid boss, the likes of which can only be obtained by the most powerful of heroic dungeon runners?

Me: Oh, alright, well, let me get…

A.: No! There is no time for that.

For not only will you need to make a raid boss, you will also need to script a bit of an event for my assistant, Luis.

Me: Right, so let me get Lui…

A.: Yes, yes, you can figure that all out afterwards. But first let me make sure you understand – this boss must be TOUGH.

I want the players hearts CRUSHED as they vie for the phat lewts contained within!

Me: I’ll make sure Travis puts some good stuff on there.

A. A.: Excellent! Now, be gone! *dramatic swing of the cape*

Me: … all you did was turn around in your chair.

A. A.: Scram.

I shrugged and wandered over to the quest pit.

Luis Barriga, a warm and friendly, if heavily tattoo’d and ripped, vegan sat docilely behind his monitor.

Me: Heeeey, Luis! Alex said you needed a quest boss… but in a raid zone?

Luis: Oh hey, dude. Ya, let me walk you through the story.

Slowly rippling flashback blurs fill the room.

Luis: Once upon a time,  a powerful man named Medivh explored the dark powers of the twisting nether from his grand tower, Karazhan.

Flashback rips.

Me: Yeah…. I know about Medivh.

Luis: Well, shush and I’ll tell you for a second what’s up.

medivh spellcasting by tircassia d7a910w
A powerful man named Medivh. (

Clouds reform. 

Luis: Medivh, possessed by Sargeras, began to tamper with the ancient layline magics, feeding additional power into Karazhan – so much that it drew the attention of the Blue Dragonflight.

Charged with the eternal protection of magic on Azeroth, Malygos, leader of the blue flight, sent his second eldest son, Arcanagos, to draw Medivh from his tower and warn him of the impending danger!

Me: *yawns a bit*

Luis: Finding the tower impenetrable by normal means, Arcanagos set fire to the village outside of Karazhan, drawing the Guardian out of his tower.

Arcanagos attempts to stop Medivh, but Sargeras corrupts the magic Arcangos flings at him, burning him from within.

Me: I’m still not hearing any gameplay here.

Luis:  *exasperated* Fine. Look, the players recover Medivh’s journal, read it on the balcony of Karazhan and get an extra boss.

If they beat him, they get access to Tempest Keep.

Me: Oh. Okay, so you basically need a gear check boss.

NightbaneLuis: Yes.

Me: Got it.

I moved to leave the office. 

Luis: He’s also a BONE dragon. Burning from the inside.

Me: Oooooooohhhh.

Mechanical Mandates

I wandered over to talk with Scott. 

Me: Okay, I have a pretty good grasp of what Luis and A.A. want for this boss.

Scott: Oh yeah? Typical one-off?

Me: Nah, they want a gear check repeatable raid boss.

Scott: Hrmmm…

Me: They also want him to be very tough.

Scott: Well, alright, I’ll go talk to Roman about a unique model.

What are you thinking for gameplay?

Me: Well, as much as I’d love to do something crazy, we’re kind of short on time here.

Scott: *nodded with more relief than I realized at the time*

Me: So I’m thinking we take the standard dragon kit – cleaves, cone flame breath, an aoe fear, then add some cinematic moments – say, a few fly-by strafing breath attacks and mostly cosmetic excitement.

Scott: Hrmm…. yeah, that sounds pretty doable.

Joe: Seems a little bit like a waste of a good view. Maybe he should stay in the air a little bit?

Me: Well, I did JUST do that with Nazan and Vazruden.

Scott: Yeah, but it will have been like 30-40 hours of gameplay since they saw him. I think you can get away with it.

Me: Erm, I mean that more in terms of I’m familiar with how to do this.

Okay, cool, I’ll go get started on this.

How hard can it be?


In retrospect, I realized that my personal preferences and biases towards the shaman character had clouded my judgment during the design process.

It was a humbling experience to understand that the game rules and the expectations of players do not align with personal desires.

So surprising, huh?

The valuable lesson I learned from this journey is that, as a designer, it is crucial to set aside personal biases and approach each task objectively.

By focusing on the broader game balance and player experience, we can create content that resonates with a wider audience and ensures a more enjoyable and fair gameplay experience for all.

Ultimately, it is important to remember that the success of a game lies in meeting the needs and expectations of the players, not solely catering to individual preferences.

By the way…

If you enjoyed reading this post-mortem, here are the upcoming learning resources we’re planning to release including post-mortems, guides, fireside chats, and courses by other industry practitioners and I.

And if you need to develop the skills to get hired or level up your career as a professional game designer, here are 2 ways you can accelerate your learning curve:

  1. Join Funsmith Club Discord and get feedback on your game project, career decisions, job hunting process from game developers of all skill levels, including myself.
  2. Use the Game Design Skill Development Program to acquire the practical design analysis and decision-making skills and framework I’ve used to
    • Revamp the Warlock class into the best player-rated version through all of the World of Warcraft expansion packs.
    • Redesign the champion Xerath, support system, and ward system in League of Legends.
    • Train and mentor junior designers in Riot Games.
    • Design enemies, combat, and the UI for the Ori and The Will of The Wisps (Average 92.8/100 ratings by 23 top game rating sites).

4 Responses

    1. We didn’t have a dwarf priest, so we mostly skipped him. I only did this boss in PUGs near the end of the expansion that were lucky enough to have a dwarf priest in the raid.

      My memories are honestly about the boss being annoying. Nothing hugely and exasperatingly annoying like Rhyolith, I didn’t _hate_ doing Nightbane, but certainly not something I enjoyed at all. I always voted to skip him. Sorry.

  1. I’ll copy what I wrote at the time:

    Ahh, Nightbane. Hmm, I thought Blizzard said that Fear was going to be less important in TBC. Quite honestly, I don’t really understand Blizzard and Fear. As far as I know, you need a warrior tank, or a dwarf/draenai priest, or two shaman to even have a reasonable chance of beating this fight. I just don’t understand that logic. Sometimes I wonder if there’s some other way of dealing with Fear that Blizzard thinks we should use.

    Personally, I think boss Fears should work more like Intimidation: everyone except the main tank gets feared. That would make Fear-based fights much easier to deal with without raid-stacking, and make non-warrior tanks/non-dwarf priests more viable.

    Aside from that, Nightbane is an okay fight. There’s nothing really interesting in the fight, it’s all about the tank breaking Fears, picking up Nightbane when he lands, and being topped off before Fear. In many ways, it’s a very tank-healer-centric, old-school fight.

    Final Grade – Nightbane: C+

  2. Ooh, this is going to be good. I tanked Nightbane in a horde guild without warrior tanks and with 1 unreliable shaman. I believe I did survive one of the fears with the old bubble-taunt-cancelaura trick and we got the kill. I always liked Nightbane because badass dragons with tons of tank damage just felt like ‘real raiding’.

    Also, the “the players recover Medivh’s journal, read it on the balcony of Karazhan and get an extra boss. If they beat him, they get access to Tempest Keep” bit is so good. This is how the raid progression is supposed to be in the ideal world.